It’s Not All Lost When Movies Like This Still Get Made

It might sound like an exaggeration to say All Is Lost is very nearly a perfect movie, but I’m going to go ahead, throw caution to the wind, and venture into this unlikely territory. All Is Lost is the best movie I’ve seen this year though, admittedly, I haven’t gone to the movies as much as I have in past years. But the movie overcomes so many hurdles that it’s hard not to get excited about it; hurdles, not incidentally, that were purposely constructed and laid out and are exhilaratingly shattered. In lesser hands these constrictions would have left us with a snoozer.

Robert Redford as our unnamed protagonist.

Robert Redford as our unnamed protagonist.

A snoozer is sort of what I was expecting. A man stranded in the middle of the ocean, struggling to survive can go very wrong. And I’ve never been a huge fan of Robert Redford. But Redford holds his own (if he doesn’t dazzle) in this smart film full of suspense and surprises unburdened by unilluminating and unnecessary backstory. Director J.C. Chandor (who helmed the exceptionally good Margin Call from a couple years back) executes those risks by showing us (not telling) the story of an unnamed man fighting for his life after his sailboat is crippled somewhere in the Indian Ocean. We suppose he’s one of those gentleman sailors who, once retired, takes up the challenge of a lone trip around the world.

We suppose because Chandor doesn’t give us a hint of anything that came before in this man’s life. A brief voice over in the first few minutes of the film (during which my heart sank, fearful that this was a taste of what was to come) gives way to a sparse, objective view of the events. Chandor discards the florid dialogue in favor of a gritty, naturalized narrative. We aren’t subjected to by-the-number explanations of everything Redford’s character is doing; Chandor assumes we’re smart enough to figure it out, eventually. And it’s refreshing to experience a movie that doesn’t spoon feed it’s plot to us.

The disaster starts off when Redford awakens from a hole punctured in the boat, water sloshing in. He finds a stray cargo container lodged into the side of his boat. (We wonder if he considers the irony: The very globalism that made his trip possible also could prove disastrous.) So he sets out to patch the hole and find his way to a port. But the water soaked his radio and laptop. No communication, no navigational tools. Back to the stars for navigation.

One mishap after another makes for an almost comically disastrous trip, but Redford faces them with a stoic resolve. He maneuvers and manipulates the materials at his disposal with a resolve that suggests a man who has spent a lifetime solving problems, though the stakes have never been higher.

I’ve heard complaints that we don’t know anything about Redford’s character. There’s no backstory, they say. It’s true. Chandor doesn’t give us anything about this character other than what we see on the screen – and the choice is glorious. All we need to know about this man is right there on the screen. His reactions, his resourcefulness, and that weathered face that tell us more than a goofy voice over ever could. It’s all there. The experiences of a lifetime distilled into several desperate days. We walk out of the theater knowing this man without knowing the details of his life. We fill that in for ourselves, and probably better than the film could have. The mawkish flashbacks, the son he regrets neglecting as a child, the wife he drove away with his alcoholism are all happily absent. These troubled pasts have become hackneyed. Once filmmakers used them to humanize their characters, but now they just feel like cheap plot points, bought and paid for at screenwriter school.

Chandor has enough faith in the audience to put those pieces together for themselves, a bold calculation in an era of dumbed-down entertainment. It was a gamble, but he pulls it off magnificently and has made a remarkably good film. Movies like this continue to give me hope, they remind me why I slog through all the terrible and mediocre ones. I just wish screenwriters and directors would pay attention, try something new, something edgy instead of churning out the same dreck year after year. Keep it up Mr. Chandor. I’m looking forward to your next film.



Filed under Current Releases

7 responses to “It’s Not All Lost When Movies Like This Still Get Made

  1. This sounds great, Jason – I was already looking forward to catching it when it is released in the UK, and am now even more eager to see it. The lack of back story sounds interesting – I’m a fan of flashbacks in the right place, but they certainly aren’t needed in every film!

    • Nice to hear from you again Judy! Yes, flashback does work in the right places, but I think you would agree you’ve seen too much of the same thing. Filmmakers who don’t know what they’re doing shoehorning in conventional backstories that don’t tell us anything about the characters, but everything about the filmmakers lack of vision and creativity. Because of Chandor’s expert directing and Redford’s good performance, I found it unnecessary in this picture.

  2. Awwww…..Jason….I can’t believe you fell for this! Fawning like all the others stumbling for ways to validate this snoozer 🙂 While it certainly had some interesting elements, and I totally GET wanting more of stuff like THIS over stuff like THAT….THIS was still not that good. I found it highly repetitive from scene to scene (it could’ve made a very tight and profound short film), thematically redundant to much of what we’ve seen in the past few years, and the ending was sooooo trite (we’ve seen this ending dozens of times).

    I can sum up my thoughts with this line from my review, “I’ve never in my life been more mesmerized and bored simultaneously” or you can check out the full review if you’re really bored 🙂

    • David, David, David.. I read your review and I tried to ignore it. 🙂 I was sad that you totally missed the point. I didn’t find it repetitive at all and I can’t ding it because there are other thematically similar movies that aren’t as good out right now.

      As far as the end goes, I could have gone either way. It didn’t bother me, though I can see why it might annoy someone who wasn’t invested in what came before.

      I can’t argue against boredom. Either you “fell for it” or you didn’t. I’m happy to say I fell for it and had a great time at the movies.

  3. Jason, great that you are back with this blog. I had actually removed the link at the WitD sidebar, because it led to a page that indicated the blog was deleted. Your return is the best news i have heard all week. And your love for this particular film is music to my ears. I’m surprised that David is not a fan, as I’ve not until now come across anyone who hasn’t been singing its praises. Your outstanding, provocative essay shows you have not lost a step. Robert Redford in a practically wordless performance gives one of the best performances of his career. I was not bored for a minute.

    Again, welcome back! I will be very happy to reinstate the link tonight!

    • I’m glad to hear you liked this one. David is allowed to miss the boat (no pun intended) every now and again. I’m sure he thinks I have many times as well.

      And thank you for your continued support. It’s always been a joy talking about movies with you and the other passionate people over at WitD.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s