“I’ll decide with whom my wife is going to have dinner and whom she’s going to kill!” –To Be Or Not to Be – Best Pictures of 1942 (#3)

Jack Benny and Carole Lombard as the first couple of Warsaw theater pose with their supporting players.

When making a comedy about a serious, emotionally traumatic event, filmmakers usually have to gauge whether or not the public is ready for its cinematic treatment. Several U.S. filmmakers forayed into the Iraq War while it was at its height and the public responded with resounding indifference. It has to be immeasurably more difficult to time the public’s receptiveness to a comedy about such as event. Comedy is hard enough under the best of circumstances, but writers and directors usually want to avoid theaters not just devoid of laughter, but chalk full of indignation. “Too soon?” they might ask while shrugging.

With To Be Or Not to Be, director Ernst Lubitsch not only didn’t bother with considerations of the public’s delicate sensibilities, but openly flaunted them and, in the process, made one of the greatest comedies of all time about, of all things, the Nazi occupation of Poland. Most filmmakers shied away from making a comedy about the Nazi occupation of Poland in 1942, when the Nazis were still kicking up their boots in Warsaw. It would have be akin to making a madcap comedy about September 11 while rescue workers were still digging through the rubble in Manhattan. (OK, maybe it’s not exactly an equivalent example; people had several years to get accustomed to the horrors of Nazi occupation while the world was shocked by September 11 in a matter of hours. Still I think the spirit is the same.)

Lubitsch, from a script by Edwin Justus Mayer, finds the perfect tone, a careful balance between madcap comedy and a serious meditation on the nature of freedom and the responsibilities it entails. In the film, Joseph and Maria Tura are a pair of famous Polish actors who get caught up in the initial invasion in 1939 and later become embroiled with Nazi spies, the Polish underground, and Gestapo stooges, despite their own overwhelming vanity and egocentricity.


The Turas play the parts of their lives.

Carole Lombard shines (as always) as Maria Tura in her final role before a tragic plane crash took her life. Lombard’s Maria is flighty, flirty, and, at first glance, completely useless anywhere other than, maybe, a stage (though we never really see Maria at work and can’t judge her ability). She begins an innocent (?) flirtation with a handsome young flier (Robert Stack), arranging to meet him in her dressing room while her hammy actor husband Joseph is on stage reciting Hamlet’s To Be Or Not to Be soliloquy, when she knows they will have plenty of time and Joseph won’t be able to disturb them. It is during one of these meetings thatGermanyinvades and the life that Joseph and Maria once had, where critics and ticket sales were the only serious considerations, is turned on its head and they get involved in a Nazi plot to capture and kill all the key members of the Polish underground. They, along with the colorful characters they work with in the theater, vow to stop the Nazi plan and save the Underground.

To Be Or Not to Be is slick, thoughtful, and, above all, immensely funny. Even Jack Benny turns in a good performance. He may have been a great radio and television talent, but his film career was decidedly lackluster, though you wouldn’t know it judging from this film.

But Lubitsch’s film is more than a vehicle for Jack Benny or a mindless comedy. It suggests that even those who appear the most frivolous in society are capable of rising to the fight against foreign occupation and tyranny. Some of the most ill-informed and apolitical will be roused to action when they see their cities and homes occupied, their friends and neighbors arrested, freedom squashed, and national identity subsumed by violence. And this, the movie argues, is why fascism will fail. It needs violence, intimidation, and repression to succeed and these tools can provoke even the silliest, like the Turas, to work against it.



Filed under 1942, Yearly Best Pictures

8 responses to ““I’ll decide with whom my wife is going to have dinner and whom she’s going to kill!” –To Be Or Not to Be – Best Pictures of 1942 (#3)

  1. Jon

    Wonderful stuff here. I agree with you. This is one of the greatest comedies ever made. In fact, I’m currently prepping my top 60 list for the Wonders in the Dark countdown. I have it placed at #11 on my own list and really wish I could squeeze it into the top 10 somehow. I love Benny and Lombard who are both top notch here and this is a hilarious film and one of the best of this year clearly.

    • Thanks Jon. Needless to say, this one is making an appearance on my own list that I’m submitting, though I can’t be at all specific about where on the list it’s ending up. It should be high though.

  2. Wow, I even got to see a placement in an upcoming comedy ballot! LOL! Anyway, Jason, this is a master class piece on an essential comedy, one that sadly for me will always bring the tragedy of Carole Lombard to the center, as (much as you note here) this were her final film. It’s one of Lubitsch’s most popular films, and how right you are to say it shows even the most frivilous capable of fighting against tyranny. There’s a bit of a kinship here with Chaplin’s THE GREAT DICTATOR, those of course Lubitsch and his marvelous cast speak their own language.

    • Yes, Lombard’s death will always slightly overshadow this film. She was an amazing talent who would have gone on to do amazing things.

      I never thought about the related themes this movie shares with The Great Dictator, but you are absolutely right. Even though I’m not a huge fan of Chaplin’s film, I think these two movies could make a great double feature.

  3. A great choice here, Jason. I especially like Jack Benny in this – his expression whenever Robert Stack starts to walk out during his soliloquy is amazing, and he is so funny but with the right edge of desperation as he tries to outwit the Nazis. Carole Lombard is great too and they work well together – such a shame that this was her last role. Very daring to make a comedy with this kind of subject matter in 1942, but it certainly worked.

    • Yes, Benny is amazing here. I watch this movie and wonder why he wasn’t more successful in film, especially when I consider how great his radio and TV shows were. Some radio and TV stars never translated well into film, but Benny shows here, with the right vehicle he did translate.

  4. John Greco

    One of my favorite comedies. I am a big fan of Jack Benny, and Lombard too, and this might just rank as his best film. As Sam mentioned, Lombard’s death overshadows the film but she definitely finished on a high note. Great review.

    • Thanks John! I am in complete agreement. This is one of my favorite comedies as well. And I do think this ranks as Benny’s best film. The rest are almost all stinkers. (Did you see George Washington Slept Here? Yikes.) However, I love his TV show and what I’ve heard of his radio program. He was a great comic and actor.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s