Only Angels Have Wings: Best Pictures of 1939 (#6)

Cary Grant and Jean Arthur in "Only Angels Have Wings"

Howard Hawks’ Only Angels Have Wings is a classic of adventure and drama. Set in a small Latin American port town, Hawks recounts the daily dramas and dangers of a group of pilots at its fledgling airfield. Led by Geoff Carter (Cary Grant) the men daily risk their lives to keep their schedule so their kindhearted boss Dutchy (Sig Ruman) will get a mail contract he desperately needs. Dutchy is on the verge of losing everything – his hotel, his store, his airfield – and Geoff is determined to get him his mail contract at all costs. Hawks introduces us to Geoff and his men through Jean Arthur. She plays Bonnie Lee, an American nightclub performer making her way home. Her ship docks in their town and she spends the evening enjoying the attentions of two pilots. She will, of course, eventually fall in love with Geoff, though he wants nothing to do with her in the beginning. She conveniently misses her boat and gets wrapped up in the high tension world of their airfield.

The romance between Bonnie and Geoff is not, as it would first appear, the main focus of the story. Perhaps Hawks trimmed her part when, as it has been reported, he struggled to get the performance out of Arthur he wanted, but whatever the reason, she serves as our introduction to this specific world of U.S. aviators in South America. She recedes into the background as the story shifts to the real meat of the plot: the pilots’ battle against the elements and mechanical failure to secure the contract, and the hostile relationship between a new pilot MacPherson (Richard Barthelmess) and Geoff’s trusted right hand man Kid Dabb (Thomas Mitchell). MacPherson has been blackballed from airfields throughout the Americas because years earlier he parachuted out of a spiraling plane, leaving his copilot to die a fiery death. The copilot was Kid’s brother and Kid has vowed revenge. Normally Geoff would not have hired someone hated by everyone else, but too many men have died and he needs to have pilots – especially a pilot who is desperate enough for a job that he can throw the most dangerous assignments at him. Geoff convinces the Kid to put aside his antipathy for the man who didn’t bother to save the Kid’s brother – at least until the mail contract is secured.

This is one of those rare movie where the leads actually end up supporting the true spine of the narrative: the subplots. Though it comes later in the film, the Kid’s hostility for MacPherson is the most emotionally resonant part of the narrative. Their relationship evolves from active (almost violent) hatred to an icy truce to mutual respect is compelling. Hawks, Mitchell, and Barthelmess develop these characters and their relationship flawlessly, allowing us to identify and empathize with both. Plus Thomas Mitchell gives one of his most nuanced and accomplished supporting performances of his career, something in which he specialized in the 1930s and 1940s.

Grant with Richard Barthelmess and Thomas Mitchell

Only Angels Have Wings is an effective white-knuckle action movie, but Hawks, like he did with all of his great movies, uses the drama to explore deeper themes. Here he asks us to consider the temporality of life in a microcosm in which death is a constant presence in the lives of its men. At one point, after a pilot has died, Geoff and the other pilots go on as though nothing has happened and he sends another pilot on the same fatal route. In a fluster with all the activity around her and unsure how to process the emotion, Bonnie exclaims, “Say, things happen awful fast around here!” Of course they do. They have to move fast both for their own sanity and for the survival of the greater good. They know that any one of them could die on their next run. There’s no use planning or saving for the future and, for those who do go on living, there isn’t much sense into getting too attached to their comrades or mourning after they die. We see similar dynamics among soldiers during wartime.

Howard Hawks was one of the true masters of the Hollywood studio system and Only Angels Have Wings is one of his best. There are lots of characters and subplots swirling around, threatening to disrupt the narrative flow, but Hawks successfully shepherds all the parts into a cohesive and entertaining whole, again exhibiting his mastery of the medium. Watch it as an entertaining adventure, a sultry romance, an example of the Hollywood studio system’s success, as a comment on the omnipresence of death in the midst of life, or any combination of these things. It will work on all levels.



Filed under 1939, Yearly Best Pictures

8 responses to “Only Angels Have Wings: Best Pictures of 1939 (#6)

  1. “Calling Barranca, calling Barranca.”

    You know, you’d wind up in a coma if you turned that into a drinking game.

    One of my favorite Cary Grant movies, very underrated generally. Nice to see it make the list in a very deep field.

  2. Great review of a great film. I love Hawks and this is one of his finest – glad to see it on your list of the best for 1939. Although Grant is mainly known for his comedies, I think he is also good in slightly more macho roles like this one. And of course there is still a lot of comedy blended in – his repeated requests for a match are funny, infuriating and heartbreaking all at once. Must say I also like Jean Arthur in this even if Hawks didn’t, and, looking back at my own review of this one, I see I put more of a focus on the romance between them than you do, Jason.

    I tend to think of this film together with Hawks’ earlier aviation dramas ‘The Dawn Patrol’ and ‘Ceiling Zero’ as there are a lot of similarities between them – the manly singsong after a death, and the ensuing row, are also there in ‘The Dawn Patrol’. Barthelmess was great in that film and it is good to see him here in such a good role so late in his career (though it was only a few years on from the last of his great pre-Codes). And, as you say, the bitterness between his character and Mitchell’s is at the core of the picture. Just to add I do think it is a pity that Rita Hayworth doesn’t get a bit more scope in her role.

    • I don’t think you were wrong to highlight the romance between Jean Arthur and Cary Grant, but I did notice watching it again that she disappears for large chunks of the second half as the flying and MacPherson dramas play out. Like you I also liked Arthur (I usually do) but from what I read, Hawks wanted her to play sexier which she wasn’t comfortable doing. He later got the performance he was looking for out of Lauren Bacall in To Have and Have Not. I am a big Howard Hawks fan and respect his judgment, but I have to say if he wanted that out of Jean Arthur, I think that was a mistake. She was sexy for her intelligence and wit, not by being sultry or anything like that. I think she would have ended up looking silly if she tried that.

      I still haven’t seen Hawks’ Ceiling Zero or The Dawn Patrol, though I did see the 1938 remake. You have been raving about them for a long time so I am looking out for them.

  3. Well, this is one I’d be hard-pressed to contest but then again, few would do so anyway. Perhaps the script isn’t on the level of the performances (which are well delineated in the comment section here with Judy) but you basically say it all now:

    “Watch it as an entertaining adventure, a sultry romance, an example of the Hollywood studio system’s success, as a comment on the omnipresence of death in the midst of life, or any combination of these things. It will work on all levels.”

    • Sam, the script is probably a bit hokey in places, but Hawks, Grant, Arthur, Mitchell, Barthelmess, Hayworth, and the rest raise the material to masterful heights. It’s a movie I have come to admire the more I watch it.

  4. I’m also a big fan of both Jean Arthur and Howard Hawks, but if he was looking for a Lauren Bacall style performance, he cast the wrong actress. That was never her thing. As Jason said, she was about brains and that dry wit and a sweetness under the cynicism. Maybe Hawks hadn’t quite figured out what the Hawksian woman would be.

    Re: the original Dawn Patrol — well worth seeking out if you can find it.

    Oh, and as for Looney Tunes spoofing “Calling Barranca” — that rings a bell now that you mention it. The delivery is so deadpan and so repetitive, it plays almost like an in-joke among the pilots.

    • I did some checking and it seems “Calling Barranca” was a regular gag in the Looney Tunes. I found this one, “Silly Saddles,” on You Tube. It comes in the very beginning, about 1:05 in.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s