The Real World and My Best and Worst Lists of 2010

*I wrote this yesterday morning when NPR was reporting Rep. Giffords had died.  What it has to do with a top ten list, I don’t know, but I was in the mood to vent.

On the disturbing and  tragic weekend when Rep. Gabrielle Giffords has been shot, several more wounded, and six others killed (including a federal judge and a nine year old girl just out to see democracy in action) in Tucson it seems fairly frivolous to publish a post celebrating my favorites of 2010. As this country drifts towards a third world economic and political system championed by blind ideologues on the Right, I feel like I need to justify my passion for movies and storytelling, though I really shouldn’t have to.  Most of my regular readers understand the power and benefit of storytellers inspiring our collective imaginations.  They remind us of the possibilities we had forgotten, the goals that fell by the wayside, and the empathy we so desperately need today.

I don’t know what motivated the shooting yesterday morning, though there are plenty of political commentators and buffoons who have been calling for violence both directly and indirectly for years now.  They suggest how the wonder of storytelling can be turned against us by weaving fantastic and paranoid tales for their own political gain.  They’ve convinced many people that Obama is a Muslim Manchurian candidate sent to subvert our country with Communistic programs.  That Obama is neither Muslim nor anywhere near is Communist is immaterial to them.  It helps further their agenda.

Whether Jared Loughner was inspired by Glenn Beck, Ann Coulter, or Sarah Palin (if your “crosshairs” map had nothing to do with guns, why did you take it down?) is almost irrelevant because they have been spearheading our descent into Banana Republicanism for years: non-regulated markets, limited social services, low taxes (especially on the wealthy), a weak educational system, and, not coincidentally, easy access to guns.  I’ve always wondered why the people who think these things are so wonderful don’t go live someplace that already has them in place, like Sierra Leone, Afghanistan, Yemen, Sudan, Somalia, and parts of Colombia.  Stays in those places would give them a taste of what’s to come here should they have their way.

Luckily there are still enough people who value truth, fact, and honesty that are willing to stand up and expose their misuse of data, twisting of facts, and omissions of truths.  Their plan to dismantle civilization ushering in a new Dark Age under the supervision of Ayn Rand’s soulless “philosophy” will not go as expected.  And, of course, one of the best ways to dilute this myopic Constitutional fanaticism and laissez-faire fetishism is to tell stories that touch people’s souls.  Maybe if more Tea Partiers saw more of the movies on the list below (and sought to understand them), they would be a little less likely to paint everyone who doesn’t agree with them or who looks different from them with the same dismissive and dehumanizing brush.  Maybe that’s just wishful thinking.

Now that I’ve made a “serious” point, I don’t feel quite so guilty about my focus on movies.  Getting back to the subject at hand, here is my list of favorite movies that were released in 2010.  I see these movies as everything that is right in our culture today, as opposed to the dishonest rhetoric like hateful political talk that goes on day and night or the absurdly ahistorical Kennedy miniseries that the History Channel has finally declined to air because, from what we see in the script, it amounts to little more than a right-wing character assassination of Jack Kennedy.  But let’s move on from this political diatribe.  Focus, Jason, focus.

This list is partial and temporary.  I loved all the movies on it, but there are still several I haven’t seen like Mother and Child, Please Give, Biutiful, I Love You Philip Morris, Godard’s Socialism, among others.  (In fact, looking at a list of releases for 2010, it’s amazing how many of them I haven’t seen considering all the time I spent at the movies.)  And this doesn’t even include foreign titles that won’t make it to us until later this year.  So think of this as a tentative list of the best, subject to many changes by the time I do this officially when I finally get here on my annual countdowns.

1. Toy Story 3

2. Another Year

3 Mother*

4. Carlos

5. I Am Love*

6. Rabbit Hole

7.127 Hours

8. Restrepo

9. The Social Network

10. Vincere*

* These are actually 2009 releases, but we didn’t see them in theaters until 2010 here in the U.S.

Best Actress: Natalie Portman (Black Swan)

Best Actor: Edgar Ramírez (Carlos)

Best Supporting Actress: Olivia Williams (Ghost Writer)

Best Supporting Actor: Ciarán Hinds (Life during Wartime)

Yes the best movie of the year is Toy Story 3.  I don’t know how that gels with those commentators who called me heartless or some other such nonsense for not liking True Grit.

Natalie Portman in "Black Swan"

Natalie Portman was stunning in Black Swan and all indications are she will get an Oscar for it.  Other close contenders were Giovanna Mezzogiorno (Vincere), Hye-ja Kim (Mother), Annette Bening (The Kids Are All Right), Nicole Kidman (Rabbit Hole), Lesley Manville (Another Year), Tilda Swinton (I Am Love), Rachel Weisz (Agora), Jennifer Lawrence (Winter’s Bone), Naomi Watts (Fair Game), and Isabelle Hupert (White Material).

Edgar Ramirez as Carlos the Jackal

Edgar Ramírez will not be eligible for an Oscar because of the Academy’s increasingly archaic rules, but he gives one of the most complete performances of the year in Carlos.  Other close contenders are James Franco (127 Hours, a movie he essentially carried by himself), Jesse Eisenberg (The Social Network), Colin Firth (The King’s Speech), Aaron Eckhart (Rabbit Hole), Jeff Bridges (True Grit), Ryan Gosling (Blue Valentine), Sean Penn (Fair Game), George Clooney (The American), Mark Wahlberg (The Fighter), Andrew Garfield (Never Let Me Go), and Jim Broadbent (Another Year).

Olivia Williams (with Tom Wilkerson) in "The Ghost Writer"

For best supporting actress I chose Olivia Williams for a mysterious and layered performance in Roman Polanski’s political thriller The Ghost Writer.  Nods should also go to Amy Adams (The Fighter), Diane Wiest (Rabbit Hole), Melissa Leo (The Fighter), Helena Bonham Carter (The King’s Speech), Kiera Knightley (Never Let Me Go), Alba Rohrwacher (I Am Love), Ruth Sheen (Another Year), and Allison Janney (Life during Wartime) *Update (Jan. 13): I forgot to include Barbara Hershey in Black Swan.

Ciaran Hinds in "Life during Wartime"

Ciarán Hinds, in an overlooked performance from an admittedly  pretty bad movie, is my best supporting actor.  How many people can make a child molester so compelling without being exploitative?  (Oh yeah, the last guy to play the part, Dylan Baker in 1998’s Happiness.)  Other close contenders are Geoffrey Rush (The King’s Speech), John Hawkes (Winter’s Bone), Miles Teller (Rabbit Hole), Andrew Garfield (The Social Network), Christian Bale (The Fighter), Max Minghella (Agora), Nicholas Duvauchelle (White Material), and Flavio Parenti (I Am Love)  *Update (Jan. 13):  How could I have forgotten the wonderful work of Armie Hammer as the Winkelvoss twins in The Social Network?*

The worst picture I saw in 2010 was The Last Airbender, an especially tedious and cynical exercise.  It wasn’t even so bad that it was funny.  It was just plain terrible.  It was made even worse when I sat down and watched the animated series and I found that M. Night failed to capture any of the humor of the characters.  Everything was so unnecessarily dark.  The creators of the show ought to be annoyed while they spend all the money.  Runners-up for the worst are Little Fockers, Paranormal Activity 2, Tron: Legacy, Burlesque, Greenberg, Micmacs, Robin Hood, and Faster.

"The Last Airbender": They don't come any stinkier

Faster also ends up as one of the most disappointing because of Dwayne Johnson’s failed attempt to get back into action, the place he should have been all along.  He looked uncomfortable in the film, like he didn’t know the cameras were running.  If he’s going to be in something this stinky he should at least throw us a bone and spend more time with less clothes on.  I have scientifically worked it out and if he had been (at least) shirtless in 65% of the movie, it would have been 84% more bearable.  (It would have still been bad, but an enjoyable bad — like eating bad blueberry pie.  No matter how bad, it is, after all, still blueberry pie.)

Other disappointments were Hereafter, Alice in Wonderland, Shutter Island, The Town, Get Low, Splice, Wall Street 2: Money Never Sleeps, Howl, and Greenberg.

And there have been a slew of overrated pictures: Winter’s Bone, Exit through the Gift Shop, Greenberg, The Kids Are All Right, True Grit, White Material, and Waiting for ‘Superman’.

All in all it was an interesting year of movie-going, if not exactly great.  There was a decent action movie (Inception), a couple of pretty good romantic comedies, which is quite a feat for this now barren genre (Letters to Juliet and How Do You Know), a charmingly goofy Christmas horror/thriller from Finland’s (Rare Exports), and a few shockingly good remakes (The Karate Kid, Let Me In, and The Crazies ).



Filed under Thoughts and Comments

5 responses to “The Real World and My Best and Worst Lists of 2010

  1. You know, I am going to sit through The Last Airbender one of these days just so I have a true gauge of how bad films can get…though is it really worse the Lady in the Water, which for my money, by far is not only Shyamalan’s worst, but one of the stupidest, most poorly made films in the history of mainstream cinema? The mind boggles at the possibility that it might be! I can’t wait to see it!

    • I still haven’t seen “Lady in the Water” so I can’t compare it to that. However, it is worse than “The Happening” which is pretty wretched and, as far as I can see, qualifies as “one of the stupidest, most poorly made films in the history of mainstream cinema.” Shyamalan is really on a roll here.

  2. Jason, there is no question in my mind at all that Giovanna Mezzogiorno gave the year’s best performance in any category for VINCERE, a film that barely missed my Top 10 list, and made yours at #10. Among actors in a leading role, I loved Colin Firth, but Edgar Martizex was tops for CARLOS.

    Your list is wonderful. I want to talk about the senseless shooting that nearly took of life of Congresswoman Giffords (who may pull through now), but I’ll take a pass for now, although admiring your terrific and heartfelt lead-in.

    Four of your Top Ten make my own list, which is posting at WitD very late tonight: Toy Story 3, Carlos, Rabbit Hole, and Another Year. As I love TOY STORY 3 deeply, I applaud your #1 selection! I am no fan of MOTHER, but you are no fan of WINTER’S BONE and THE KIDS ARE ALL RIGHT, so I guess it goes both ways. I like THE SOCIAL NETWORK well enough, but less than you, in much the same way I like WHITE MATERIAL more.

    But this is a diverse and passionate list and presentation all the way through, and I commend you for including the likes of I AM LOVE and RESTREPO. I preffered WASTELAND, INSIDE JOB, JEAN-MICHELE BASQUIAT , JOAN RIVERS and THE TILLMAN STORY amongs docs, but who can argue your choice. (I regrey not seeing MARWECOL yet, though)

    I largely agree with your “disappointments” with the notable exception of SHUTTER ISLAND.

    All in all, an exquisite list by one of the most passionate and eloquent film lovers out there. It’s been a real pleasure all year Jason!

    • I tend to agree with you that Mezzogiorno may deserve the nod as best actress, but “Vincere” is really a 2009 release so I’m holding back on selecting her, instead favoring someone from a 2010 release.

      This is the first I have heard you didn’t like “Mother”! That surprises me. I thought it was a compelling, surprising, funny, tense, and all around wonderful movie. But I guess you’re right. My dislike of “Winter’s Bone” and my unenthusiastically positive assessment of “The Kids Are All Right” even that out.

      Sadly I haven’t seen any of the docs you listed except “Joan Rivers” which I enjoyed. But this is why this list is, as I said, tentative.

      I am looking forward to your own choices! I’m also looking forward to another great year of movie going interaction with other great movie lovers like you!

  3. Pingback: Stage Play “Beirut,” Documentary “Waste Land” and “Gulliver’s Travels” on Monday Morning Diary (January 10) « Wonders in the Dark

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s