Best Actress of 1934 – Ruan Ling-yu (The Goddess)

Other Noteworthy Performances: Bette Davis (Of Human Bondage), Marlene Dietrich (The Scarlet Empress), Carol Lombard (Twentieth Century), Dita Parlo (L’Atalante), Myrna Loy (The Thin Man)

Bette Davis’ Mildred Rogers, the flirty but malicious gold digger in Of Human Bondage, repelled but mesmerized audiences.  Audaciously unlikeable with her transparent emotional manipulation and financial exploitation of crippled Leslie Howard, Davis delivered the best English language performance of 1934.  It is generally acknowledged that the Academy robbed her of an Oscar when they failed to even nominated her.  A write-in campaign could not break the puzzling It Happened One Night sweep, bestowing the Best Actress award to Claudette Colbert.  Though she dominates the English language field, Chinese actress Ruan Ling-yu work in The Goddess surpasses – only slightly – Davis’ performance.

Whereas Davis’ Mildred uses men for her amusement, Ruan’s nameless character is trapped – there are few legitimate employment options for a single woman and the few are full.  The only alternative to feed and house her son is prostitution.  For this choice (if it can really be characterized as such), she and her son are shunned in their neighborhood.  But she does not worry about the disapproval of her neighbors so long as she can afford to send him to school.  She is determined to provide her son with the tools to make a life for himself better that which she has made for him.  Her almost single-minded determination compels her to make dangerous choices, such as hiding money from her violent pimp, but anything to improve her son’s prospects is worth the risk.  She is strong, but only because she has to be for her boy; we get the sense that she would lose her spunk if she weren’t a mother.  But even with her son as motivation she does not have an endless well of strength.  When the school’s principal comes to possibly expel him because of gossip about her, she breaks down.  The fragile life she has built and the tentative future she envisions threatens to fall apart and she crumbles, pathetically begging the man not to ruin her son’s life because of her transgressions.

Yes, this is an explicit celebration of motherhood, but the boy’s appreciation for his mother – the “goddess” – will only come later (maybe).  What’s important is her devotion to him (especially the sacrifice at the end).  Like most children, he will not understand and value what she has done for him until much later, often too late.

Ruan Ling-yu, like Harry Baur, is an underappreciated actor today.  Both died too soon, limiting their output.  Baur died at the hands of the Gestapo during the Nazi occupation of France and Ruan committed suicide only a year after The Goddess opened.  Both were exceptional actors for movie lovers of any language and, though they died before their times, they have left clear evidence of their talent.  Ruan Ling-yu should be especially remembered today for her timeless, touching part in The Goddess.



Filed under 1934, Yearly Best Performances

5 responses to “Best Actress of 1934 – Ruan Ling-yu (The Goddess)

  1. Aye Jason, this is no contest, as Ling-yu gives an extraordinary, heartbreaking performnce (one of two from this period–the other was in THE PEACH GIRL) and it may take some time before many come across it. Every one of your runners-ups are worthy (yes, a write-in campaign that year from Davis didn’t have a chance from Day 1, but it led to an underserved win for DANGEROUS, unfortunately) and there is only one I would add to this mix and that is Madeleine Renaud for her beautiful performance in Duvuvier’s MARIA CHAPDELAINE.

    Lovely essay on Ling-yu.

    • Thank you as always. I haven’t had a chance to see “The Peach Girl” or “Maria Chapdelaine” yet, but I will take you at your word. But I hope “The Goddess” is rediscovered more generally and gets the recognition it deserves.

      As for Bette Davis, yes they gave her a consolation Oscar in 1935 for “Dangerous,” but actually delivered a fine performance as the alcoholic actress in that movie. You are right that it was undeserved as there was at least one finer performance that year (more on that in a couple of weeks).

  2. Pingback: William Castle, Ozu, 3D Festival, ‘Milk of Sorrow’ and ‘Animal Kingdom’ on Monday Morning Diary (August 30) « Wonders in the Dark

  3. Looking at your postings for 1934, I realised I hadn’t seen most of the films and really need to catch up with a lot from that year. I haven’t seen ‘The Goddess’, though from your comments and Sam’s it sounds like a must, but am pleased to see you also mentioning Bette Davis in ‘Of Human Bondage’ as I think she is magnificent in it – showing just what she could do if she was given a good part instead of all the routine stuff Warner kept pushing her way. Also love Lombard in ‘Twentieth Century’.

    • Yes, Bette Davis is fantastic in “Of Human Bondage.” I really wanted to pick her, but I couldn’t overlook Ruan Ling-yu’s heartbreaking performance. I have a feeling I will give Davis her due sometime later down the line. And I’m sure Sam would agree that seeing “The Goddess” is a must. It is a great movie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s